Mikes2014

Icon

eclectic mix of michael's musings

The Melbourne Football Club – what next?

As a passionate Demon supporter, it is with great sadness to see the appalling start to the 2012 season. First, there was the sad, but inevitable death of Jimmy Stynes. Then , the seemingly endless difficulties with their very talented indigenous playing list. And then, to top it all off, their major sponsor went rogue, in an unbelievably vicious and bigoted way – very un-MFC. As someone who has admired the sensitivity and inclusiveness with which the Administration has handled incredibly difficult issues over the years (Austin Wonnamiri, Liam Jurrah and now Aaron Davey), Melbourne of all Clubs does not deserve the complications that have befallen them this year.
Having said that though, their poor form can largely be put down to a slow start by their senior players: Maloney, Jamar, Green, Rivers, Frawley, Davey. They are not even playing several of their first round draft picks in their second, third and fourth years at the club: Morton, Bleeze, Gysberts, Strauss, even Lucas Cook. Injuries have not helped either: Sylvia, Martin Jurrah, Gawn. All these issues have contributed, but not to the extent of a 100+ point thrashing in the West.
I think a lot of this can be put down to inexperience both at the Board level and in the coaching group. I suspect the MFC will become a case study in the future on how to not handle crisis in organisations, whether it be in companies or football clubs. What it does show, as has been shown so often in the past, is that dissention and instability are “death” to any organisation.
So what can be done to turn it around? First, the coaching group has to somehow get the senior playing group up and running. Secondly, they need to return to their talented early round draft picks and give them their head. Thirdly, they need to pick the strong bodies in the key positions and tell them to throw their weight around.
There are no easy solutions here, but the new coaching group will be defined by what goes on in the next 6-8 weeks.
Go Dees!

Filed under: Australian Rules, Melbourne Football Club, Uncategorized, , , , , ,

Who will make the Australian Five Olympic Road Race Riders?

With the early success of Green Edge this season, and the listless start by both Mark Cavendish and Cadel Evans, suddenly the Olympic road race may not be the foregone conclusion many had feared. In my view there are three reasons for this:

  1. it is 240 km, not 130km as in the Olympic test event won by Cavendish. Cavendish has traditionally not been good at longer distances especially when it is accompanied by significant climbing;
  2. it has significant hills: in fact a hill of 2.4 km at a 7% gradient. Cavenish showed in the recent Milan-San Remo that if teams put the hammer down up hill, he can’t cope with it, and the race will run up this hill 18 times (in the test event it was 7 times); and
  3. he does not have the key lead-out men (Matt Goss and Mark Renshaw) he had at HTC last year, and it is starting to make a difference. In the flat course in Denmark at last year’s world championship (won by Cavendish), the lead out was fulfilled by Bradley Wiggins, but this year Wiggins will be in the mix for the general classification in the Tour de France which will finish just two weeks before the Olympic race, so he is unlikely to have the stamina for a significant contribution here.

It is interesting to analyse the Australians’ tactics in the recent Milan-San Remo, a race not unlike the Olympic one – long , fairly hilly, and very, very fast. Green Edge had two main men: Simon Gerrans and Matt Goss. Gerrans was supposed to cover any moves by the main players up the hills near to the finish, and Goss to cover the sprint if it ended in a bunch. Gerrans performed his part brilliantly, and showed he is now a racer of substance, and has probably moved into favouritism for the Olympic race.

So who should be in the Australian teams for the Olympic race?

  1. Gerrans and Goss pick themselves;
  2. Heinrich Haussler – although not yet a Green Edge rider, he did a brilliant job in being a lead-out man for Goss at the last world champs. He should be there;
  3. Stuart O’Grady – as there are no radios in the Olympic road race, it is vital that there be a wise old head directing traffic for each team. There are none better than O’Grady; and
  4. the last position is the hardest. In my view it needs to be someone who can sprint up the hill time and time again to wear the Brits out. I can think of none better than Cadel Evans for this, but like Wiggins, he is likely to have just come off three weeks of hard racing in the Tour, and probably will not be in any condition for such a tough race. Alternatively, I would go for someone like Luke Durbridge with his legendary engine, or Richie
    Porte with his climbing ability. This is the toughest of all to fill, and may in the end come down to how Cadel feels after the Tour. As he will be in the team for the time trial, it will be possible to fill this spot at the last minute.

Whatever decisions are made, Australia goes into this race with probably the best chance ever of coming home with the Gold for this event. A first in Australian Olympic history, after many very near misses.

Filed under: Cycling, London Olympics 2012

The Robbie Slater/Craig Foster “feud”

The latest “beat-up” by Robbie Slater  in criticising Craig Foster’s perfectly reasonable  criticism of Melbourne Victory’s latest show of incompetence ( says much more about Slater than Foster. This is not the first time Slater has sought to insinuate himself into debate going on around him by making frankly silly remarks. He can be seen in my view as the “Bill O’Reilly” (in reference to the US Fox News commentator) of the Australian sporting media where the more outrageous the remarks the more he seems to think he will be taken seriously. It is not by accident that Slater always seems to be put in the second tier of Fox Sports Football commentators – never seems to get the gig commentating overseas on the Socceroos, gets second tier A-League matches to call, because frankly he is not very good.

Mind you, Foster has at times been rightly accused of hubris  in his commentating duties, such as the time at the last World Cup when after Australia lost 4-0 to Germany he suggested that all the past Socceroo captains should go down to the team’s dressing rooms and arrange a replacement for the coach (Pim Verbeek). His alliance with the pompous and antiquated Les Murray  (the “Ffffff…ossie and Sir Les show” as Roy and HG call them) can at times be ponderous and downright embarrassing, but overall I think Foster is one of the more considered and thoughtful of our football commentators, and has the Australian game’s successful development at heart.

So I say “Congratulations Craig Foster”. You are spot on about the Melbourne Victory’s “back to the future” in appointing the less than distinguished British coach. It is a great pity we cannot continue the European approach in football philosophies and tactics which has served us pretty well as an emerging football nation. For a football-mad nation like England, where a disproportionate amount of its sporting resources are devoted to the game, it has been singularly unsuccessful. Certainly Australian Football can always learn from the best, but Australia is most successful in sport when we look at the best in the world and adapt their practices to our own very strong and unique sporting culture. England is a long way from the best in the world in football.

Filed under: Football, Sport, , , , ,

Michael Liley

 

May 2012
M T W T F S S
« Apr    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

Politics

Top Clicks

  • None

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 10 other followers

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.